Facebook's Experiment, What They Did Wrong

In case you missed it, Facebook recently conducted an experiment whereby they altered the emotional tone of hundreds of thousands of people's page feeds to see if that affected their emotional state. And it did. They published their results, and now there's a big fuss about it and how it is unethical as it lacked informed consent etc.

I think this is a fascinating debate. People are justly upset at being manipulated in this way. I would be too.

Here's where Facebook went wrong: they published their experiment. If they had kept quiet we would not complain.

Am I mad? How would facebook's silence have made this okay? It wouldn't have. But it would have made their experiment exactly like the emotional manipulation conducted by all large marketing organizations.

Those soulful dark eyes on the forlorn girl advertising for world vision. The cheerful family and soccer mom used to guilt us into buying life insurance. These are chosen in the same way, and to influence our feelings.

In the same way politicians use immigration, or families or religion to tweak our feelings towards their cause.

World Vision

Image: World Vision Inc. worldvisionmagazine.org

Don't think for a moment that these people don't know what they are doing. Marketers, politicians, businesses employ experts to conduct exactly the same kind of experiment to find out how best to sway you in the ways they want.

What Facebook did wrong was to tell us they did it, and to do it for an ignoble cause, that of pure knowledge. If they had done it to make you buy stuff you don't need, or to vote for someone. That would have been okay.

And if what Facebook did was not okay, we need to be discussing these others, the marketers and politicians. Simply by pretending they do not do this, we have allowed them to get away with it. Perhaps we should challenge that now.

Gerard V is unreal! Amazing night!!!

Gerard V

Gerard V is a comedy hypnotist entertainer based in Australia, New Zealand, and the Pacific including the USA and sometimes Europe . He does shows for companies, clubs and charities where he works live on stage with audience volunteers that he has never met before.   Gerard VTel: +61 468 419 994

Blog Categories


Gerard's blog. Mostly show related but other stuff too.

Entertainment ideas

Interesting, fun, or unique entertainment ideas for your events.


Interesting, fun, and other info related to fund raising.


Ideas and other info related to fund raising.

Hens stags and bucks

Posts Relating to Pre-wedding and Wedding Entertainment Events

Hypnosis faq

Common questions about hypnosis

Party ideas

Ideas for parties and smaller events

Show faq

Frequently asked questions about the shows.


A Blog About Sleep and Sleeping, Naps, Napping and Good Health

Small groups

Posts relating to small events

Successful fundraisers

Ways to make your fund raising show more successful.


Testimonials from Corporates, Schools and Clubs

The show

FAQ about the show.

Venues faq

Things I am asked about what kind of venues work well.


Excerpts from shows, and other great stuff.


Things we can do for that Special Day